A Real Question We Hear After Every Storm Season
After a spring storm passes through Edmond, we start getting calls from homeowners who all say something similar. They know their roof took a hit, but they are not sure what comes next or what type of shingles actually make sense for Oklahoma weather.
One of the most common questions we hear during an inspection is about composite shingles vs architectural shingles in Oklahoma, and which option is better for homes in and around Edmond.
At Honor Roofing & Construction, we take a straightforward approach. Our job is to explain the differences clearly, based on what we see on real roofs every day, so you can make a decision you feel confident about.
Here’s what we’ll cover in this guide:
- The real difference between composite and architectural shingles
- How Oklahoma weather affects both materials
- What to think through before replacing your roof
- Cost, durability, and long-term performance
- Common questions we hear from Edmond-area homeowners
If you want a broader foundation before diving in, our Roofing 101 guide for OKC homeowners walks through roofing basics, insurance considerations, and what to expect from a professional inspection.
When you are ready for next steps, Honor Roofing & Construction can help with a clear inspection and honest guidance.
Why Shingle Choice Matters in Central Oklahoma
In Oklahoma, roofing decisions are shaped by weather first and everything else second. We deal with hail, strong winds, intense sun, and fast temperature changes. A roofing material that performs well in another region may not last here.
We have replaced roofs that were only a few years old because the wrong material was chosen or because installation did not account for local conditions. Choosing the right shingle starts with understanding what your roof faces year after year.
Defining the Two Shingle Types
Architectural shingles are asphalt shingles made with multiple bonded layers. They are thicker than standard 3-tab shingles and are designed to provide better wind resistance and longer service life.
Composite shingles are manufactured using synthetic materials such as polymers or recycled components. They are designed to mimic the look of slate or wood while offering improved consistency and impact resistance.
Local Factors That Matter
- Oklahoma building codes require Class A fire ratings
- Wind uplift ratings are critical in storm-prone areas
- Hail impact resistance can affect repair frequency
- Insurance coverage often depends on material type and condition
For a deeper look at how materials perform locally, we break that down in The Best Roofing Material for Oklahoma Homes, which focuses on durability in real Oklahoma conditions.
What to Know Before Choosing a Shingle
Before deciding between composite and architectural shingles, there are a few practical considerations that should come first.
Budget Planning
Architectural shingles are typically more affordable upfront. Composite shingles cost more initially but may last longer and require fewer repairs over time. Your plans for the home matter here.
Insurance Considerations
If storm damage is involved, insurance coverage may influence your options. We provide hands-on insurance guidance during the inspection so you understand what is covered and what is not.
Permits and Code Requirements
Roof replacements require permits in Edmond and surrounding areas. Working with a local contractor helps ensure everything meets current code without delays.
Roof Design and Structure
Composite shingles are heavier than asphalt. Roof slope, framing, and ventilation all affect whether they are a good fit. That is why a proper inspection comes first.
Composite vs Architectural Shingles for Oklahoma Homes
Architectural Shingles
A dependable option for many Oklahoma homes
Architectural shingles are the most common roofing material we install. They offer a balance of cost, availability, and performance that works well for many homeowners in Edmond.
Pros:
- More affordable than composite options
- Wind ratings commonly range from 110 to 130 mph
- Easier to repair after localized storm damage
- Widely accepted by insurance providers
Cons:
- Granule loss over time is common
- Lifespan can be shortened by repeated hailstorms
Architectural shingles can be a solid choice when installed correctly and paired with proper ventilation.
Composite Shingles
Built for consistency and impact resistance
Composite shingles are engineered products designed to handle tougher conditions. Many homeowners consider them when they want added durability and a longer service life.
Pros:
- Expected lifespan of 30 to 50 years
- Higher impact resistance options available
- Better color and shape consistency over time
- Reduced cracking compared to asphalt
Cons:
- Higher upfront investment
- Fewer contractors have hands-on installation experience
- Repairs may require matching specific products
Composite shingles can make sense for long-term homeowners who want to reduce future repair cycles.
Cost Perspective
Architectural shingles remain the lower-cost option at installation. Composite shingles cost more initially but may balance out over time depending on storm exposure and maintenance needs. During inspections, we walk through real numbers so homeowners can compare options clearly.
Deep Dive: Durability, Warranties, and Local Risk
Hail and Impact Performance
Hail is one of the leading reasons roofs are replaced in Edmond. Composite shingles often carry higher impact ratings, while architectural shingles may show wear sooner after repeated storms.
Warranty Coverage
- Architectural shingles typically carry 20 to 30 year manufacturer warranties
- Composite shingles often include longer coverage periods
- Proper installation is required to maintain warranty protection
As certified installers, we follow manufacturer requirements closely so warranties remain valid.
Energy Considerations
Both shingle types are available in reflective options. However, attic ventilation, underlayment, and installation quality play a larger role in energy performance than shingle type alone.
How We Help
Our role is to guide homeowners through these tradeoffs during the inspection. We focus on what makes sense for your home, budget, and long-term plans, not on pushing one product over another.
Edmond Homeowners’ Guide to Roofing: Common Questions Answered
If you’re comparing roofing materials or thinking about replacing your roof after a storm, it’s natural to have questions. Below are some of the most common questions we hear from Edmond homeowners during inspections, answered clearly so you can move forward with confidence.
Are architectural shingles durable enough for Edmond storms?
Yes, architectural shingles are durable enough for most Edmond storms when installed correctly. They’re rated to withstand winds between 110 and 130 mph and perform well in typical Oklahoma conditions. Regular inspections can help catch early damage after hail or wind events.
Are composite shingles worth the added cost in Oklahoma?
Yes, composite shingles are worth the added cost for homeowners who want longer lifespan and better hail resistance. They’re engineered to handle impact and weather-related wear, which can reduce long-term repair needs, especially in hail-prone areas like Edmond.
Will insurance cover composite shingles if I’m upgrading from asphalt?
Insurance may not fully cover composite shingles if you’re upgrading from asphalt. Most policies only cover like-for-like replacement unless you have prior approval or endorsements. We help review your policy and walk you through your upgrade options during the inspection.
How long do architectural shingles typically last in Oklahoma?
Architectural shingles typically last between 7 to 10 years in Oklahoma due to frequent hail, wind, and sun exposure. While manufacturers may list longer lifespans, local weather often shortens that timeline.
Do composite shingles require special maintenance?
No, composite shingles do not require special maintenance beyond regular inspections. They hold up well to sun, wind, and moisture, and don’t lose granules like traditional asphalt shingles.
Can I switch from architectural to composite shingles on my home?
Yes, you can switch from architectural to composite shingles, but only if your roof structure supports the added weight. We check for structural compatibility during the inspection and help you choose the right system for your roof.
Choosing the Right Shingle with Confidence
When comparing composite shingles vs architectural shingles in Oklahoma, the right answer depends on your goals, your home, and how long you plan to stay there. Both materials can work well when installed correctly and chosen for the right reasons.
At Honor Roofing & Construction, we are a BBB-accredited, local company built on honor, honesty, and workmanship. We focus on clear communication, skilled labor, and helping homeowners feel confident in their decisions. We are here to serve our community, create a lasting legacy, and provide opportunities through hard work and craftsmanship.
If you are weighing your options or dealing with storm damage, the next step is simple.